What laws are unjust and should be broken? Should they be broken? Would the correct path be to fix or change these laws?
We asked the good questions when discussing Thoreau, but were we honest? When does practicality take over and stamp our free will, our intentions of justice?
I, for one, would not be willing to go to jail for breaking a traffic violation (though I might push the speed limit a bit.) However, I would harbor a fugitive slave if I could not afford that person the freedom I am blessed with.
When is it just to take matters into one's own hands? Is it still just if your actions of breaking said law hurts others? Where do we draw the line?
I believe if we are not careful, we could take this idea of civil disobedience and find ourselves in the middle of anarchy. The problem is, everyone's perception of justice or fairness varies. We don't all have the same moral code. We aren't even affected by the same stimulus. What we need to do is think before we act. Think carefully.
There are always opportunities for standing up for what is right. Sometimes we have to create those opportunities. And if that doesn't work...
Friday, October 28, 2011
Saturday, October 22, 2011
Truth
What is truth? (Well, that was not what I expected to be quizzed about!)
So what is truth? I think it is the absence of pretense. There is no denial; no subterfuge; no mask. It is sincerity and understanding. It can be virtuous.
Truth is not always exact, but it can be. Facts can play a part or supposition may weigh heavily on the truth. Perception is certainly a player in defining truth.
Most truths are intermingled with supposition and flat out lies.
Black and white? Rarely.
So what is truth? I think it is the absence of pretense. There is no denial; no subterfuge; no mask. It is sincerity and understanding. It can be virtuous.
Truth is not always exact, but it can be. Facts can play a part or supposition may weigh heavily on the truth. Perception is certainly a player in defining truth.
Most truths are intermingled with supposition and flat out lies.
Black and white? Rarely.
Friday, October 14, 2011
Mary Rowlandson
As I was re-reading this captivity narrative, I wondered how many actual thoughts and feelings were left out. I decided to do the same with my impression of this piece of literature. I found my free writing to be vague and plagued with inconsistencies when compared to my original thoughts.
This realization only reaffirmed my impression of the coercion that must have been present when Mary Rowlandson wrote this reflection. She not only had dry excerpts void of emotion, she displayed biblical quotes and hanging comments glorifying the actions of her husband and the views of her Puritanical faith. If she were merely reflecting on her experience, I would imagine that their would be more emotional passages evident throughout the narrative.
It is amazing the powerful hold a religion or society can have on an individual. I am thankful every day that I am able to think freely and make my own choices. Free will is a blessing and freedom is sacred. We have the opportunity to change and create our laws in this country as well as practice our religious preferences.
This realization only reaffirmed my impression of the coercion that must have been present when Mary Rowlandson wrote this reflection. She not only had dry excerpts void of emotion, she displayed biblical quotes and hanging comments glorifying the actions of her husband and the views of her Puritanical faith. If she were merely reflecting on her experience, I would imagine that their would be more emotional passages evident throughout the narrative.
It is amazing the powerful hold a religion or society can have on an individual. I am thankful every day that I am able to think freely and make my own choices. Free will is a blessing and freedom is sacred. We have the opportunity to change and create our laws in this country as well as practice our religious preferences.
Saturday, October 1, 2011
Education as an American "Right"
As Americans we often consider everything we do as our American "right." However, we are looking at education the wrong way. We may have a right to education, but it is a privilege, a blessing.
In the "No Child Left Behind" act we are attempting to "catch up" in the education race. We don't want any child left in the dust. According to Obama, the original act encourages teachers to teach to the test which has invited some states to lower their standards "in a race to the bottom." This downward spiraling race removes the room for diversity and well-rounded individuality. It also sets some children up to fail. The Act is flawed.
Don't get me wrong. I want everyone to have the opportunity of a successful education. I just feel that where we went wrong was losing the passion. If the teacher demonstrates a passion for teaching, then that will inspire a passion for learning in his/her students.
For example: my child's math program is Everyday Math. A few of us (parents) addressed the school with the program problems only to be told bluntly that quite a bit of money was spent on the program and it met the criteria of the state standards: there would be no change. All we wanted was for a little more time, practice, and the passion of teaching to be integrated into the program. Their response was exactly the kind of "tamping down" that we do not need in education.
People have different learning styles and learning speeds. This applies to our children. In the attempt to keep America competitively smart, we are losing the edge of the fast-paced learners and the alternate-subject talented individuals. The alternately talented individuals no longer have the time to pursue their special subjects because they are struggling to keep up with the state standard schedule. We are also creating unnecessary anxiety in teachers, children, and parents to "hit the mark." Allowing a diversifying schedule of completion in our schools would allow the fast paced to shoot forward and the others to "get it" at their pace and experience the confidence that comes with successful learning.
In the "No Child Left Behind" act we are attempting to "catch up" in the education race. We don't want any child left in the dust. According to Obama, the original act encourages teachers to teach to the test which has invited some states to lower their standards "in a race to the bottom." This downward spiraling race removes the room for diversity and well-rounded individuality. It also sets some children up to fail. The Act is flawed.
Don't get me wrong. I want everyone to have the opportunity of a successful education. I just feel that where we went wrong was losing the passion. If the teacher demonstrates a passion for teaching, then that will inspire a passion for learning in his/her students.
For example: my child's math program is Everyday Math. A few of us (parents) addressed the school with the program problems only to be told bluntly that quite a bit of money was spent on the program and it met the criteria of the state standards: there would be no change. All we wanted was for a little more time, practice, and the passion of teaching to be integrated into the program. Their response was exactly the kind of "tamping down" that we do not need in education.
People have different learning styles and learning speeds. This applies to our children. In the attempt to keep America competitively smart, we are losing the edge of the fast-paced learners and the alternate-subject talented individuals. The alternately talented individuals no longer have the time to pursue their special subjects because they are struggling to keep up with the state standard schedule. We are also creating unnecessary anxiety in teachers, children, and parents to "hit the mark." Allowing a diversifying schedule of completion in our schools would allow the fast paced to shoot forward and the others to "get it" at their pace and experience the confidence that comes with successful learning.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)